The
images are structured in a similar way, with a group of people under a flag,
but they still convey drastically different messages. Both images depict the
current situation from a limited perspective. For example, in the “Saved”
poster, the Jews continue to look distraught even though the Americans have
rescued them. Other than the word “Saved” at the top of the picture, there is nothing
else in the poster that indicates that the Jews indeed were saved. The picture
only considers the continuing effects of the psychological trauma on the Jews,
rather than showing the physical benefits of attaining freedom. The Nazi poster
also explains the effects of the war from just one perspective. The Nazi poster
shows beaming faces and a bright sky, as if the country is peaceful and
prospering, with little to suggest the violence and brutality of the Nazi
regime.
In
both pictures, the characters all have nearly identical appearances. The mice
in the poster all look dejected and weary in their prisoner outfit, expressing
how Auschwitz spared none of the Jews, inflicting an unimaginable degree of despair
and trauma on all of them. The Jews also continue to wear the striped prisoner uniforms
from Auschwitz. In the background, the portion of the American flag with
stripes is above the Jews, suggesting that the Jews consider their rescue to be
a different type of prison, in which they are trapped by their memories rather
than abused physically and emotionally by the Germans.
The
Nazi poster depicts Germans who all have nearly identical uniforms and faces of
pride and joy. The poster reflects how the Germans favored their own race over
all others. The Germans all wear military uniforms, and there is a castle in
the background, reflecting the strength of German society. The Nazi flag is being
hoisted into the sky, mirroring the rise of Germany as a world power. Even the
clouds in the background are white and fluffy, a stark contrast to the lethal
gases in the Auschwitz chambers.
Both images also depict
a character at the forefront who seems to best embody the emotions of the
people in the background. Vladek best embodies how lasting the effects of the
torture in Auschwitz were; he habitually confuses the past and the present, as
when he refers to Art as Richeu in the end of the novel. The man at the
forefront of the propaganda poster raises the flag and leads
the salute, best demonstrating Germany’s pride in their racial and military
superiority and their “avid [desire] to achieve greatness for
Germany” (Rinderle).
The images are both created to send a very specific
message about trauma, as in Maus, or national pride, as in the Nazi poster. Neither
is focused on the realities; rather, they promote a biased view of the situation.
Perhaps a more balanced view of the predicament, equally weighing the positives
and negatives, would have been the best way for people to cope with the war and
its aftermath.

No comments:
Post a Comment